Why Hosts Lose Guest Damage Chargebacks
If you’ve ever charged a guest’s card for damage and then lost the chargeback, you’re not alone. Waivo’s Grace Huggins recently joined David Goodale, CEO of Merchant-Accounts.ca, on the Merchant-Accounts.ca Podcast to talk about why guest damage chargebacks are so hard to win and how short-term rental owners can protect themselves.
David has worked in payments for 25 years and once owned vacation rentals himself. Even so, he said he didn’t realize how stacked the rules are against property owners until one of his clients lost a chargeback he should have won. Waivo is not your ordinary vacation rental damage protection company. We’ve revolutionized the industry by creating a unique approach to handling guest-caused damage, one that doesn’t burden your guests with responsibility or paperwork. We handle everything behind the scenes, ensuring a smooth and pleasant experience for everyone involved in the midst of a situation that is often a negative one.
You can also read David’s take on the conversation in his post on property damage chargebacks and Waivo.
The Toy Train That Cost a Host Thousands
David opened with a story about a client who owns several vacation rentals in rural Hawaii, all on septic systems. The client’s terms and conditions covered flushing rules, and a sign in the bathroom spelled them out too. A guest’s child flushed a toy train anyway, and it got stuck in the pipe.
The owner did everything right. He had photos of the damage, photos of the posted policy, and signed terms. He still lost the chargeback.
Grace said this isn’t unusual. Waivo sees situations like it often, and recovering money from guests in short-term and mid-term rentals is very difficult.
Why Hosts Lose Guest Damage Chargebacks
The problem is how the card brands handle damage. As David explained, both Visa and Mastercard require explicit consent from the cardholder for charges made after an incident. If the guest doesn’t agree to the damage charge, the host will likely lose the dispute, no matter how clear the rental agreement is.
In David’s words, Visa and Mastercard are methods of payment, not a legal enforcement contract. You can charge the card, but you often can’t keep the money.
The Hidden Cost: Retaliatory Reviews
Even when a host could win, chasing a guest for damage carries its own risk. David recalled his very first booking in Barbados, where he chose to agree with a difficult guest rather than risk a bad review. After that, he never enforced a damage deposit, because a bad review could cost more than the broken item.
Grace pointed out that programs like Airbnb’s AirCover require hosts to go after the guest first, and that’s where many retaliatory reviews come from. One bad review can cost you Superhost status, remove a “guest favorite” badge, and push your listing lower in search results. Lower visibility means fewer bookings, which can hurt far more than paying for the damage yourself.
How Waivo Handles Guest Damage
Waivo is supplemental guest damage protection for short-term rentals, backed by Lloyd’s of London. You add a damage waiver to a booking, and if guest damage happens, you come to Waivo instead of the guest.
- No guest communication, ever. Waivo never contacts the guest for money or even more information, so there’s no risk of a retaliatory review tied to the claim.
- Reimbursed by ACH. You get paid back and walk away from the booking without a loss.
- Built for everyday damage. Waivo expects clients to have guest damage and wants them to use the program. Claims don’t automatically raise your rates. Only a client with consistently heavy damage, like a party house, might see a rate increase or cancellation.
- Small and large claims. Grace’s examples ranged from a $70 lamp, red wine stains, and dog scratches on doors to a $5,000 broken window at a luxury property. One surprisingly common claim: broken hot tub control panels.
What Does Waivo Cost?
Waivo offers two programs:
- Waivo Enterprise is built for property managers and larger operators. It has booking volume and property count requirements, and it comes with lower rates and a more seamless process.
- WaivoNow is built for homeowners and managers with one to three vacation rentals. It is a self-serve model and offers customization options.
New to Waivo? Read Who is Waivo? or how Waivo got started.
Grace’s Advice for Rental Owners
- Have a plan for guest damage. At some point, you’ll have it. Setting money aside can help, but you never know whether it will be enough.
- Be transparent with guests. Clear house rules and clear instructions, like how to use the hot tub, prevent a lot of accidental damage. They also make you a better host and help you keep Superhost status.
Frequently Asked Questions
Get in Touch
Ready to stop chasing guests for damage? Submit a consult request here.
